We know not if it’s nurture or nature that dictates who you become. Though, no matter what is proven, we can ascertain that nature and the events it subjects you to definitely have a potent influence over who you become. Though, the question lies in; Would you be the same person you are, were you to have lead a different life or experienced different events as did you in the one herein? Were you to have been raised through a different environment, under different circumstances, and/or surrounded by a different set of people- would you still be the same exact person, or would you have changed? This is the question I’ll discuss, a question that’s been pondered upon for a while.
It is known that the idea that who we are is based on nature to be pure theory with not much basis in reality while it is definitely known that nurture, or the way by which we were raised and what we’ve experienced, definitely plays some role as to how we develop and who we become. Often it is pondered why Hitler did not employ the use of biological weapons during World War II, seeing all immoralities he committed in order to win. It is thought that why he didn’t was due to an unfortunate event that occurred whilst being a soldier and experiencing the ill-effects of a biological weapon and left him scarred and with antipathy towards biological warfare. So, here is it observed why Hitler did not engage in a form of warfare that could have led him to victory- something he was so desperate to achieve, and tried to obtain through even more unorthodox and morbid means. Another thing is that most people can account for the source of many of their fears- a fear of spiders, heights, and the dark can all be attributed to fear of death. However, in this generation, most of the things I stated prior are not lethal as were they prior to mankind’s domination of Earth, yet this ancient fer remains as a memory of a time in which we needed to survive and the dark, venomous creatures, and heights could cause us our ill end.
However, neuroscience believes that the sense of “self” is very deeply rooted within our minds insomuch that amnesia and brain trauma very rarely causes a loss of this sense of “self” we have. Is this statement proof that it’s due to our innate, human nature that we act as we do? Or is it purely due to nurture by which we are who we are? This alone cannot answer the question, though it does help to know that we could forget all our memories of events that supposedly shaped us and still retain a sense of self, even though, to us, the events did not ever occur. And I believe everyone does have facets of themselves that seemingly bare little relevance to what they’ve experienced and how they were raised, there’s always just that one aspect of which we cannot account for.
There are those few of which cannot attribute their behavior to nurture. Those of which behave in ways that are unwarranted for their living situation and their experiences. For example, I’ve severe depression despite leading a life I can describe as perfect under my perception thereof. Both sides of my family have no relevant history of mental illness, and no events within my life warrant such behavior and feelings towards life, yet these things are still felt. Problem is, I cannot attribute mine afflictions and behaviors purely to nature, as I know many things of which I partook caused the way I behave towards specific things. Therefore, I assert that thus is what I believe is true in regards to whether be it nurture or nature that governs us:
Taking the Many-Worlds Theory as true, I theorize that throughout all world lines either you’d remain practically the same (of course there’d likely be minuted details in which you differ) regardless the situations that played out through your reality, or that the events that shaped you are fixed points across all world lines-though, of course the events would differ, though they’d effect you much in the same manner, thus producing the same outcome. This isn’t nurture or nature, however, it’s actually nurture AND nature. Were this true, it’d be completely natural for fate to force upon you the events that shape you, however this also means that nature relies on nurture somewhat to produce that of which is natural, thus are both present.